1870-CC Coronet $5 Half Eagle

In 1839, the Coronet half eagle made its debut. Designed by Christian Gobrecht, this coin is often called the Liberty Head type. In 1866, the coin’s appearance was modified by adding the motto IN GOD WE TRUST above the eagle on the reverse. The Coronet half eagle was issued every year through 1908.⁽¹⁾

A man named Abraham “Abe” Curry started up a settlement in 1858 along the western edge of the Nevada Territory. Curry named his small town “Carson City.”

Shortly thereafter, just a few miles away, some of the largest gold and silver deposits in North America were discovered. The fabulous find, known as the Comstock Lode, attracted thousands of fortune seekers into the area, transforming little dusty Carson City into a booming frontier metropolis.

When Nevada was awarded statehood in 1864, Carson City was selected as the seat of state government. Eventually, a U.S. branch mint facility was built there as well.

The Carson City Mint officially commenced coinage operations on January 8, 1870. Abraham “Abe” Curry, the man who worked so hard to bring a mint to the western Nevada town, was named the first superintendent of the facility.⁽²⁾

Gold coinage production at the neophyte mint did not get off to a rousing start. Only 17,372 gold coins bore the “CC” mintmark in 1870, of which 7,675 were $5 half eagles. Contrast that to the established San Francisco Mint, where over one million gold coins (mostly $20 double eagles) were struck during the same timeframe.⁽³⁾

As was true with all early Carson City coinage, the 1870-CC half eagles were plunged into the regional economy, where they served dutifully for many years, but would ultimately suffer a high attrition rate. Few were saved by collectors of the time, explaining why there are only an estimated 77 survivors for clamoring numismatists today.⁽⁴⁾

It wasn’t until after the turn of the century when the 1870-CC half eagle became acknowledged (sort of) as a collectible. In a 1911 sale, auctioneer B. Max Mehl describe lot 663 as "1870 First Half Eagle of this [CC] mint. Very fine. Rare." It sold for $6.75.⁽⁵⁾ That same coin, if graded as a VF-20, could sell in the current marketplace for about $40,000.⁽⁶⁾

Only one die pair was used to strike all the 1870-CC half eagles, but it is important to note there are two die states. Die State I displays sharp definition of the central design elements of both sides of the coin. Die State II shows obvious weakness in the same spots.

These die states probably did not occur because of die wear. The distinct die states most likely occurred due to improper machine set up during one or more of the batch runs. Either the top and bottom dies were spaced too far apart or the pressure setting on the machine was not correct. Only about 25% of the survivors display the sharpness of Die State I: these examples usually command premiums at selling time.⁽⁷⁾

Fascinating Fact: One of the finest known examples of an 1870-CC half eagle was spotted protruding from the ground in 1994 by a Carson City mailman working his route. He sold it to a local coin dealer whose shop was across the street from the former mint building (now a museum). Eventually, the coin was certified as MS-61 (Die State I) and sold at auction in 2012 for $105,750.⁽⁸⁾

For the discerning collector, there appears to be no downside risk in owning an 1870-CC Coronet half eagle. We have charted value trend records back to 1950, and it’s impossible to find evidence of a sustained price slump or irrational price hikes. Instead, values just keep going Up, Up, and Up! This is to be expected for a great rarity that also carries the allure of the Old West, an attraction many coin hobbyists find irresistible.

Preview of eBay selection (on super rare coins like this one, the HERE link may yield better results than the Preview):

Trendline Avg = 22.64	BETTER

Last updated 9-7-23		Return to Key Date Coin List
Compare to Common Date Coin of Same Type
Download Charts to Your Computer

More about RareCoins101.com